I appreciate your input, however, there are few problems that I see with such approach:
draffutt wrote:wouldn't it be more logical if the boarding team failed that there is a very good chance the player would lose the troop ship as well (a very high chance)? Due to the defence teams either destroying or capturing for their own use....
Every ship has a pilot who stays at the cockpit ready to take off (undock) at any moment if things go bad. And stations do not have mounted weapon to be able to destroy the ship either. The ship does not undock because station forces it to undock, but because a bunch of not-so-friendly security personell is making its way down to docking bay for a "friendly chat".
Chance of boarding ship to be destroyed would effectively limit the choice of boarding ship to a TP as it is the cheapest and would have the least impact on player if it is lost. This in turn would limit boarding to relatively safe sectors where TP can actually survive the trip to its destination and back out.
Also, imagine you are boarding a military base with an M2, if random factor says you should loose your boarding ship folks would just reload until random factor says otherwise, because a fully outfitted M2 is a very expensive unit to be thrown away on a flip of a coin, thus, completely negating the very same random factor. Afterall, your ship does not suddenly explode or gets boarded by your enemy if you failed ship-to-ship boarding in "vanilla" version.
draffutt wrote:Wouldn’t it also be logical; even thou the boarding team succeeded in capturing the stationed surviving marines are lost. Maybe base it on how many survived when they attempted the hack. There are many examples in history where troops achieved the objective but where lost themselves.
Some stations require 5 stars marines both in combat and hacking. If I knew they don't have a chance in hell to come back, I'd simply never send them, as it is a very lengthy process to get them trained that high, and is not cheap either.
Just like in "vanilla" version, survivors get to live to tell the tale, at least until next boarding.